Who We Are

New Ways of Thinking About People

Amelia Belongs on The Transplant List

Doctors should not judge quality of life

 

Children's Hospital of Philadelphia declined to place three-year old Amelia on their waiting list for a kidney transplant because she has mental retardation (now called intellectual disability.) Without transplantation, Amelia is expected to live only for a number of months. Because I have a background on this topic, I have put together this post to disseminate information and support the petition for Amelia to be added to the transplant list.

In 2002 I was dying from an autoimmune disease and underwent a liver transplant. In that year a little more than 16,000 Americans underwent a liver transplantation and a year later about 92 percent of us were alive. Transplantation works, especially for livers and kidneys. It saved my life and it likely would save the life of Amelia.

At the time I was transplanted I was the head of a developmental disabilities center at The Ohio State University Medical Center. I started a program called "Lives Worth Saving." I recruited to the program Linda Jones, who was a former director of our local Organ Procurement Program. For a few years we spoke with many parents, doctors, and policy people about the issue.

Find a Therapist

Search for a mental health professional near you.

In my view it is up to God, not Children's Hospital, to decide whose quality of life merits transplant. Cadaver kidneys are rare, and to get one, Amelia will have to match closely to one that become available. That match at the right time is in God's hands. If we let doctors decide whose life is worth saving above and beyond the match, we are going to go down a slippery slope.

Lives Worth Saving produced a review of the literature. This is one of the research reports USA Today has cited.  I found it on the Internet for those who want to access it immediately. To find the full article, which is online, google: reiss organ transplant.

The petition for Amelia is at www.change.org.

 



Subscribe to Who We Are

Steven Reiss is Emeritus Professor of Psychology and Psychiatry at The Ohio State University.

more...